现代程序正义政治哲学

正义是哲学关注的永恒焦点。在近代以前,正义一词主要是作为人之行为的评价标准而存在;近代以后,正义的概念则被越来越多地被专门用作评价社会制度。程序正义作为正义的重要表现形式,一直是东西方学界研究的热点,当代正义理论的集大成者罗尔斯从分配正义入手,把程序正义的概念导入到自己的正义体系当中,具有划时代的意义。然而,正所谓“誉满天下,谤满天下”,罗尔斯通过超历史主义手法构建的正义价值体系也受到了东西方学者的广泛批评。在我们看来,正义原则的前提和根据只能在人类的历史中去寻找。因此,本文将以马克思的唯物史观为理论依据,通过生产力与生产关系的基本运动来探讨政治意义上程序正义的可行性、必要性与可能性,阐释程序正义在不同的历史时期表现出的具体形态,并指明政治意义上程序正义的局限性及其历史超越。最后,立足于政治意义上程序正义唯物史观的浅析浅析,我们将展开对现在程序正义理念的浅析浅析讨论,梳理其条件,整合其要素,阐释其理念,并论证程序正义与实质正义的关系。

【Abstract】wWw.shuoshilunwen.com Justice is the eternal focus of philosophy. Before the modern times, the term justice mainly just exists only as criteria to evaluate human behior; after modern times, the concept of justice was specifically increasingly used for evaluation of social system. Procedural justice as an important expressive form of justice has been research focus of the Eastern and Western academic. As a master of the contemporary theory of justice, Rawls started to study justice from distributive justice and introduced the concept of procedural justice into his own justice system, which was the epoch-making significance. However, as the saying goes,“When comments are over the word, vilifications are also over the world”, the justice system constructed through the ultra-Historical ways by Rolls has been widely criticized by Western scholars.In our views, the premise and origin of justice principle can only be found in the history of mankind. Therefore, this paper will study the feasibility, necessity and possibility of procedural justice; show the specific form of procedural justice in different historical periods according to the Marxist’s historical materiali and the variation of the productivity and production. And clarify the limitation and historical transcendence of procedural justice in political sense. At last, we will discuss the modern ideal of procedural justice based on the analysis of historical materiali procedural justice in political sense, with the purpose to carding its factors, integrate its elements and to interpret its ideas, and then to argue the relations between procedural justice and substantive justice.

【关键词】 正义;程序正义;实质正义;唯物史观;
【Key words】 justice;procedural justice;substantive justice;historical materiali;

相关论文

平等主义正义G.A.柯亨和当代西方政治哲学

摘要:当代西方政治哲学的主题之一是分配正义,即社会的利益与负担该如何分配才是正义的。上个世纪七十年代罗尔斯《正义论》的出版,标志着规。
浏览量:23510 点赞量:7002

现代程序正义政治哲学

正义是哲学关注的永恒焦点。在近代以前,正义一词主要是作为人之行为的评价标准而存在;近代以后,正义的概念则被越来越多地被专门用作评价社。
浏览量:44806 点赞量:10421

托尼政治哲学

作为一名具有社会主义思想倾向和基督教信仰的学者,托尼对资本主义整个的价值观和生产关系表现出强烈的不满。他认为私有制、阶级系统、自由。
浏览量:6094 点赞量:2123

哈耶克自由主义政治哲学评析

本文在政治哲学的视域下,对哈耶克的自由主义思想进行了系统的研究。全文力图在自由主义这一整体不足背景下对哈耶克的自由思想进行脉络梳理,。
浏览量:10170 点赞量:3724

近代英国政治哲学中公民社会理谈

公民社会(Civil Society),又译为市民社会。最早出现于西方,在西方不同历史发展背景下,公民社会有着不同的涵义。严格意义上的公民社会是。
浏览量:13824 点赞量:4710